All I want for Christmas is… the ESV Study Bible?

esv

If you’ll permit me, I’ll give you a little window into my insanity: my most exciting present this Christmas (admittedly, I’m only getting three) is by far and away my brand spanking new ESV Study Bible. Ok, so my other two presents were shoes and a pillow, but it still is quite exciting.
However, there are some things already, despite having not yet taken possession of my seasonal gift, that annoy me about the ESV Study Bible. Without wanting to get all bar-humbug, here they are in no particular order:

1. It’s the size of a small child. Literally.

heavy

If you don’t believe me, the evidence opposite is surely enough. I’d therefore consider it to be more of a reference book than anything I would seriously consider taking along with me to church or homegroup… unless I happened to be taking along a fork-lift truck or seriously needed a workout.

2. It’s a man’s Bible, developed by men, for men.

2,752 pages, 2 million words, 20,000 notes, 80,000 cross-references, 200+ full-color maps, 40 all-new illustrations, over 50 articles, more than 200 charts… It’s an awesome set of stats. But as Nick Page points out in his hilarious (but semi-serious) rant on the issue, there is one less sparkling one: “… looking down the list of the 95 contributors, one thought struck me: they’re all blokes.” Let’s be clear, just because all the contributors have testicles, it doesn’t render their work completely useful. It does, however, indicate that their work will have a certain slant, or err, smell.

3. There is a ridiculous level of hyperbole around the ESV Study Bible.

Take Mark Driscoll’s ringing endorsement or that of CJ Mahaney :

I can’t imagine a greater gift to the body of Christ than the ESV Study Bible.

Really? Nothing? There is a conspicuous lack of balance in many of the endorsements of this translation, and it all feels a little too much like the kind of regard many people still have for the King Jimmy. I have great respect for many of those who are endorsing the ESV Study Bible, but I can’t help wishing people would just calm down a bit and eat a few less blue Smarties.

4. It should have been called the Reformed Standard Version

The translation is genuinely very good, and an excellent word-for-word style translation. I’m sure its Conservative bias (hey, all these things will have subjectivity) will really annoy me after 5 minutes but it definitely deserves a place on my bookshelf. I think that Kenny Pearce provides a really useful way forward in seeing a way to both understand where the ESV is coming from, and accept it:

it is the very best translation if you are consulting a Bible while reading or otherwise learning Reformed theology.

Whilst I’m not even close to considering myself either ‘Conservative’ or ‘Reformed’, I do appreciate much of the informed scholarship that many who consider themselves to be those things bring to the table. Despite these frustrations, I’ll therefore be reading and digesting the maps and commentary happily for a fair while yet I’m sure.

This post hasn’t attempted to be a complete review of the Study Bible, so you may find these websites on the subject useful (I’ve certainly found them to be informative):

… Read Part 2 of this article.

4 thoughts on “All I want for Christmas is… the ESV Study Bible?

  1. Hi there,
    Just wondering what covering you opted for for your ESV study bible? I’m currently looking to invest in one but can’t make up my mind about what cover to go for. I can’t handle hardcover bibles so for me it’s a choice between genuine leather or tru-tone. There is only £10 difference in price so I don’t mind on that front. My concern is that the tru-tone might not weather well over the years (I’m intending the bible to be an investment), but I have also heard reports of the covering on the leather ones not lying flat when the bible is sat on a desk. So I can’t decide which one would be better… What did you go for and has it served you well?
    Thanks!

    Like

  2. Thanks for your comment – I went for bonded leather and it now looks like this when flat: http://twitpic.com/gckz5
    I’ve been very pleased with it and it has worn well. As I said in my post, a big bug bear for mr is the size! I agree with your concerns about the tru-tone. I don’t think the ‘build quality’ is quite as high…
    Enjoy your purchase whichever you go for and may it be well worn out with many hour of reading!

    Like

  3. Thanks for your reply! Can I just ask you a couple more questions about the leather cover? Is it still stiff like new, or has it softened up over time – and if so, to what extent? Does the bible stay open no matter which bit of it you’re reading or does it try to close itself?Thanks again,
    Estel

    Like

  4. No problem – all leather softens a little with use – if anything I’d say it makes it more ‘homely’! It stays open pretty easily after a bit of use – obviously Psalms stays open much easier than Genesis but after a bit of use it’s fine.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s